Outlook Overview: You Can Go Your Own Way
- The key issue for the economy, policy and asset allocation is the scale of the decline in core inflation and when inflation targets will be sustainably achieved. In turn this determines when central bank policy rates will peak in the DM space and the timing and magnitude of easing in 2024 and beyond. This has been complicated by March’s banking sector turbulence in the U.S. and Switzerland. On balance, we do not see a systemic banking crisis (here), but rather an enhanced credit squeeze that hurts activity and ends DM tightening before some central banks desire. In contrast, it is less important whether the U.S. and EZ economies have a modest/small recession or a phase of stagnant growth, though this would have tactical impact on policy and markets.
- Divergence is also a key theme and hence our Outlook title for March. Economies can go their own way with the U.S. dominated by the lagged impact of monetary policy and China driven by the reopening. Europe also has monetary policy tightening feedthrough and the prospect of gas and utility prices being much lower than mid-2022. We still look for a borderline recession in the U.S., a three quarter recession in EZ and 5.8% growth in China in 2023.U.S. and EZ headline inflation has peaked and we see the prospect of more downside surprises in EZ than the U.S. China CPI inflation will likely remain controlled. For the Ukraine war the balance of risks has now switched to a frozen conflict rather than the war dragging on into 2024. Meanwhile, Japan will likely increase the 10yr yield cap further to 0.75% in autumn 2023, though we do not see the BOJ abandoning QE with yield curve control.
- EM countries will show more resilience than DM countries in 2023, both as currencies have not been destabilized by 2022 USD strength and EM policy tightening is close to finished. Ongoing post COVID recovery tailwinds remain into early 2023, as reopening was later than the U.S./Europe. Some scope does exist selectively for rate cuts to start in late 2023 (e.g. Brazil).
- For 2024, we see scope for ECB rate cuts to arrive before the Fed, as we feel that the ECB has brought rates too high with core inflation likely to fall back and wage inflation better controlled than the U.S.Fed easing will likely not arrive until 2024, as the Fed keeps policy restrictive to ensure that core PCE inflation comes back towards target. Most other DM countries (except Japan) and EM countries (ex-Turkey) will likely also see 2024 rate cuts, as inflation comes under better control.
Risks: More aggressive Fed tightening to 6% plus would cause a U.S. recession and a deeper selloff in U.S. equities with a delay in the market recovery until 2024.Such a policy shock would initially hurt government bonds as well, but yields would then pivot to hopes of aggressive easing in 2024. The other key risk is that the U.S. imposes major sanctions on China for supplying lethal weapons to Russia, which would hurt the global growth outlook – we see this as a modest probability risk.
Figure 1: Economic Scenarios
Source: Continuum Economics
Market Implications
- Government bonds: March’s yield decline means that rate peaks/2024 rate cuts are largely discounted at the long-end, though the short end still has scope for yield to decline once official rates peak and central bank communications eventually prepare for rate cuts. The key theme is thus yield curve steepening. We prefer short-end of the curves in the remainder of 2023 and into 2024.10yr yields in major market will see modest negative total returns in the remainder of 2023.
- Equities: U.S. equities are overvalued relative to real yields and too optimistic about the Fed cutting rates in 2023.This can prompt a mid-year dip, which will likely be amplified by a crisis over the U.S. debt ceiling. Scope exists to 3800 potentially 3500, before recovery hopes kick in and we see a recovery of the S&P500 to 4200 by end 2023 before 4700 for end 2024. DM equity market will likely follow the U.S. and EM to outperform – especially Brazil and China (Figure 2).
- FX: The USD will continue to decline versus DM currencies, as overvaluation is reversed. For most currencies this will be at a slow pace, as yield differentials will slow the decline in the USD. We see EUR/USD at 1.12 and USD/JPY 120 for end 2023. EM currencies are more mixed, though we see appreciation of the Brazilian real.
- Commodities: Oil demand is being underestimated due to China reopening and the ongoing rebound in global tourism. With OPEC+ likely to only increase production quota by 0.5mln b/d, we see WTI to $85 by end 2023.
Figure 2: Asset Allocation for 9 Months to end-2023
Source: Continuum Economics. Note: Asset views in absolute total returns from levels on March 27 (e.g., 0 = -5 to +5%, +1 = 5-10%, +2 = 10% plus).
Figure 3: Key Events and Critical Uncertainties
April 15-16 2023 | G7 Ministers' Meeting in Japan | This meeting will discuss climate, energy and environment and will be held Sapporo. |
May 4 2023 | UK local elections | In what may be the first major electoral test for the latest government, local elections covering directly elected mayors and unitary authorities take place. |
May 19-21 2023 | G7 Summit in Japan | This Heads of State annual summit will take place in Hiroshima. |
May 14 2023 | Turkish presidential and general elections | The probability that incumbent President Recep Tayyip Erdogan makes an exit has been increasing, not least because inflation is costing him the support of his working-class constituency. Those who have gained under his policies, i.e. large exporting businesses, and die-hard supporters will continue to support him, but public support may be waning in a cost of living crisis. The opposition candidate has been named as Kemal Kilicdaroglu, main opposition party CHP’s leader. Nationwide popular mayors of Istanbul and Ankara will also join him during his campaign. |
May – August 2024 | South Africa national and provincial elections | The diminishing popularity of President Ramaphosa and ANC will lead to the end of the party’s single party government. The most likely outcome is a coalition between ANC and DA. This is not likely to lead to a breakthough in the electricity crisis, which is restraining S Africa growth. |
September 7-8 | G20 Leaders Summit India | India wants to pursue goals for the global south with better food and energy security for vulnerable countries and constructive talks on debt restructuring. However, the Ukraine war and U.S./China competition will also features heavily at the summit. |
October 2023 | Argentina general elections | The president and vice president are elected. Additionally, one-half of the Lower House and a third of the Senate are renewed. The primaries, which often act as a nationwide poll, are scheduled for August. After the defeat of the government in the November 2021 midterm elections, some excitement arose about a change of course of economic policy in 2022-2023, but we think that it is still far too early to conclude this. |
November 12 | APEC Summit in San Francisco | APEC summit with the main focus being on a potential visit of President Xi to the summit and bilateral meeting with President Joe Biden. |
No later than Dec 10 2023 | Spanish general election | Starting from May 28, a whole series of regional elections will give an incremental insight into how the general election may unfold late in the year. Current PM Pedro Sanchez has committed to the current parliament lasting its full term, with this likelihood all the greater given the manner in which his Socialist Party is faring poorly in opinion polls. The fact that Spain assumes the EU presidency in H2 2023 complicates matters as the government will have other priorities! |
July 2024 | Mexico General Election | Mexicans are going to elect the President to serve a six-years term, bear in mind that incumbent President Manuel Lopez-Obrador is not going to be a candidate as Mexican Constitution vetoes re-election. Additionally, 128 members of the Senate will be elected for a 6 years term and 500 members of the Chamber of Deputies for a 3 years term. Lopez-Obrador Party MORENA is likely to win the Presidential election and holding the majority of the two chamber but a 2/3 control which would allow Morena to pass legislation by itself is an unlikely scenario as the traditional parties PRI and PAN will also hold a significant number of seats. |
November 5 2024 | U.S. Elections | Barring a significant deterioration in health, President Joe Biden is likely to be the Democratic candidate. If he decides not to run the Democratic primaries may see a large number of candidates. The Republican primaries are likely to see a close contest between former President Donald Trump and Florida Governor Ron DeSantis. The election is likely to be close. Congress will remain closely balanced too, but the Senate map will make it hard for the Democrats to sustain their current narrow majority. In the House, it is Republicans who will be defending a narrow majority. |